With GTA 6 less than two weeks away, Polygon took a look back at the critical paper trail the series has left since 1997. The outlet ranked ten mainline entries by their Metacritic scores on original platforms, skipping expansions, GTA Online, ports, and the very first three games — though GTA 2 still made the cut at number nine. It's a tidy snapshot of how Rockstar's reputation hardened from "mixed bag" to "institution" over two decades.
The list reads like a timeline of the studio learning its own strengths. At the bottom, GTA Advance on Game Boy Advance scores a 68; Eurogamer's Kristan Reed called it "not the Grand Theft Auto experience most people will be gunning for" back in 2004. Polygon's own Josh Broadwell recently noted it's "more fun to talk about than it is to play," while acknowledging it prototyped street races, vigilante missions, and the radio-station obsession that would define later games. GTA 2 follows at 70, dismissed by IGN as "a rental at best" and described by GameSpot's Jeff Gerstmann as "the same old game" despite a more complex mission structure.
The PSP era holds the middle ground
Vice City Stories (86) and Liberty City Stories (88) sit at eight and seven respectively, both praised for cramming a console-scale sandbox onto Sony's handheld. Reviewers at the time flagged the same friction: empire-building mechanics were fresh, but the core loop was showing wear. 1UP's Kames Ransom-Wiley wished Rockstar had "fix[ed] obvious flaws that have been called out repeatedly," while GameSpot marveled Liberty City Stories existed at all on PSP, even if Toni Cipriani's mob story felt thin. IGN's Juan Castro spotted the future, though: "finishing the main story portion leaves around 60% of the game to experience."
Chinatown Wars proves constraints can sharpen design
At number six, Chinatown Wars on Nintendo DS hits 93 — the first entry to crack the 90s. The AV Club argued the hardware forced Rockstar to strip away "hours of talk-radio banality" and focus on police chases and rampages. Eurogamer's Tom Bramwell gave it a perfect score, calling it a triumph that "actually improves" the formula in the process. It remains the only top-down GTA since the PS1 era to land in critical rarefied air.
What the ranking leaves out — and why it matters
Polygon's methodology excludes GTA Online entirely, noting there "aren't many actual reviews for the latter, because it's an evolving, always-on experience." That absence underscores how the series' longest-lived chapter operates outside traditional criticism. The first three games — GTA, GTA London 1969, and GTA London 1961 — are also absent for lack of enough reviews to generate a Metacritic score, yet GTA 2 appears at number nine, a small inconsistency in the cutoff.
The bar GTA 6 steps into
Every game from number five upward sits at 95 or higher on Metacritic. GTA 6 arrives into a critical environment where the floor is effectively a mid-90s average. Rockstar hasn't confirmed a price beyond reported figures of $79.99 standard and $99.99 Ultimate, and the PC version remains unannounced. For now, the ranking serves as a reminder: the series' worst-reviewed mainline entries are still playable curiosities, and its best have rewritten what open-world games can be. The next chapter launches November 19 on PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X|S.







Comments
Discuss on r/GTA6Sourced ↗No comments yet. Be the first to say what you noticed.